Why Indians Often Feel Ungrateful Towards Muslims: A Critical Analysis

Every year, the cycle of remittance and employment benefits from Muslim-majority countries to India continues, with millions of Indians enjoying the fruits of such work. Despite this, there remains a sense of ungratitude towards Muslims among some Indians. This article delves into the reasons behind such feelings and challenges the assumptions that often fuel this negativity.

Exploitation and Benevolence: Separating Fact from Fiction

It is often claimed by some that India is the largest recipient of remittance from Muslim countries, with millions of Indians enjoying employment benefits given by Muslims. However, this claim is increasingly being questioned. The Gulf countries, flush with petro-dollars, do not require their citizens to work hard. Instead, they rely on foreign labor for essential tasks, including menial jobs. The days of slavery have long passed, and workers are now entitled to fair pay and benefits.

In fact, there is a stark disparity in pay between expatriate workers and local citizens. While multinational corporations such as those in the United States seek to justify lower wages for expatriates, the Gulf countries do not follow the same practice. Many expatriates, including non-Muslims, are paid less than their local counterparts. This has led to accusations of exploitation.

Discrimination and Misunderstanding

Social media and discussion forums like Quora have been platforms for questioning the employment conditions and the nature of these remittances. Some Indians have been labeled as maichiaya (coward) and ghisa-pita (charity), epitomizing a sense of ingratitude towards the very source that supports much of their employment.

While some Indians do indeed receive remittances and employment benefits, these are not acts of charity but rather essential work providing for families. The idea of these expatriates working as zakat (charity) is often a misconception. The reality is that such workers contribute to their families' survival and well-being.

Misplaced Brotherhood and Real Appraisal

For some Indians, especially those from Muslim backgrounds, there is a sense of shared brotherhood with their Gulf counterparts. However, this notion is often misplaced. While Arabs and Gulf citizens appreciate Indians, they often do not consider them on the same level as others. Indians and non-Muslims are often viewed as more valuable and trustworthy.

Take, for example, the concerns raised over the Pakistani Prime Minister's stance on Gulf countries' policies. Despite receiving foreign aid, he continues to criticize the region's internal and external policies, which is often seen as an act of ingratitude or even disrespect.

Education and Integration

It is imperative that Indian Muslims, particularly those employed abroad, get the education and skills necessary to integrate into the global workforce. This includes understanding the importance of fair wages, professional conduct, and ethical behavior in the workplace.

Similarly, Pakistani Muslims should focus on teaching their leaders the value of gratitude and respectful conduct. They should also foster a sense of unity with their compatriots in India, recognizing the mutual benefits of a strong, harmonious relationship with their neighbors.

In conclusion, the ungrateful sentiment towards Muslims among some Indians is often based on misperceptions and misunderstandings. As we continue to engage in global trade and migration, it is essential to address these issues and promote mutual respect and understanding.