Why Conservatives Feel Defended and Placed on the Offensive in Today's Culture War

Conservatives often feel on the defensive, and this is more than just a mere reaction to political attacks. The political landscape has shifted, particularly since the rise of the 'culture war' issues. Let's dissect why this is the case and the broader implications.

The Shift in the Republican Base

Over the past couple of decades, the liberal/conservative divide has become increasingly defined by educational attainment, particularly among white Americans. The Republican Party has effectively capitalized on this trend. According to demographic data and electoral analyses, the United States now has an electoral system that overrepresentation of rural white people who are less likely to obtain college degrees. These people have become the core base of the Republican Party.

Jason Forson pointed out, 'Over the last couple of decades as “culture war” issues came to the fore the liberal/conservative split largely became a split around education. White people without college degrees are now the Republican base.'

The Political Implications

This demographic shift has been favorable for the Republicans politically. Due to the current electoral system, the Senate is likely to remain nominally Democratic for some time, making the Republican base feel secure and firmly established. However, the situation is different in terms of non-political power and influence. Major organizations and corporations require significant credentials, which often exclude conservatives from leadership positions. This limits their potential to implement changes through alternative media and other means.

The Republican base is 'falling into the hands of liberals because you don’t get to the top of major organizations without major credentials.' A significant number of conservatives, like those in the Federalist Society, are already grappling with this reality, even changing their rhetoric to advocate for corporate control under false pretenses of small government.

The Defensive Posture

Conservatives are often defensive because they feel that their values, traditions, and way of life are under attack. This defensive stance is a response to a perceived loss of power and influence in both political and non-political arenas.

Some conservatives understand that 'their talk about small government was always a lie' and others openly advocate for a fascist-like coordination policy, yet organizational changes are difficult to implement given their rhetoric about protecting freedom and values.

A Personal Perspective

Personal accounts further illustrate this sentiment. Many conservatives feel that their moral values and the fundamental aspects of American society are being questioned and undermined. A significant concern is the shift in work ethic and the perception of work. In recent years, the value of hard work and perseverance has been challenged, with an 'good enough for me, pay up' mentality becoming more prevalent. This shift is particularly concerning when it comes to the value placed on experience, education, and self-sufficiency.

The defensive posture is also fueled by the impact of government programs on economic behavior. For instance, there have been instances where individuals have received unemployment checks that resulted in a higher income than if they were working full-time.

The Role of Science and Tradition

Another critical issue that causes defensiveness among conservatives is the integration of empirical science and tradition. The emphasis on science-based ideas often creates a conflict with traditional values and beliefs. For example, the acceptance of gay marriage, which has been the traditional view for centuries, is now being challenged. This change is seen as heralding a slippery slope that could undermine other foundational values and ideas.

Conservatives often feel defensive when old-fashioned ideas are dismissed or replaced by unproven and impractical ones simply because they are considered new. The acceptance of gender identity as a ‘fact’ is seen as a significant shift in societal norms, one that many believe will lead to further societal changes that are unpredictable and risky.

A Call for Balance

Ultimately, the defensive stance of conservatives is a complex issue rooted in changing societal dynamics, shifting value systems, and the political landscape. While the data and personal anecdotes create a compelling narrative, it is essential to seek balance and understanding in these debates. By acknowledging the concerns and values of all stakeholders, we can work towards a more inclusive and nuanced society.

It is hoped that this analysis provides a nuanced understanding of why conservatives feel defensive and placed on the offensive, promoting a more informed and empathetic conversation.