Why Aren't EU Leaders Elected Through Direct Voting?

Why don’t the public directly vote for the leaders of the EU? Is this undemocratic?

The history of many EU member states is intricate, marked by right and left-wing junta and dictators, most recently being elected through democratic systems in the 20th century. As a result, European elites have developed a deep distrust of democracy. They deliberately excluded it from the administrative structure of the EU to ensure that leading nations could appoint individuals sympathetic to the status quo. This exclusion also prevents the expanding membership from exercising democratic power that might disrupt current conditions.

The Role of MEPs and a Limited Democracy

There is an appearance of democracy in the form of voting for Members of the European Parliament (MEPs). However, MEPs cannot initiate legislation but can only vote on proposals presented by the Commission, greatly limiting their power in practice. This systemic restriction on their authority is a testament to the rigorous measures taken to preserve the status quo.

When Ursula von der Leyen was presented for the office of President of the EU Commission, she did not receive an overwhelming endorsement. This scenario potentially highlighted a significant risk for the future: MEPs could rebel if a controversial candidate were presented. This instance suggests that there is still a semblance of democratic power within the EU that could, in theory, overrule the nominated candidate's agenda.

The Evolution of EU Governance and Future Challenges

The EU has not previously been tested on this scale. It remains unclear how they might further design out this possibility, echoing the appointment of Hitler as German Chancellor. The establishment initially did not want him but he gained the role through the strength of his Party, making it impossible to resist. Could a similar scenario unfold on a cross-Europe scale?

Recent political upheavals in France, Italy, and Germany, as well as right-wing governments in Eastern EU states, have raised significant concerns. These developments could potentially challenge the established order, leading to a further erosion of centralized control. The EU faces numerous challenges, including economic recessions, loss of global influence, and energy crises. It will be essential to observe how the EU evolves in response to these challenges.

The Importance of Transparency and Accountability

The undemocratic practices within the EU highlight the need for greater transparency and accountability. The exclusion of the public from direct decision-making in key leadership roles undermines democratic principles and fosters distrust among the populace. As the EU continues to evolve, it is crucial to ensure that democratic mechanisms are robust and inclusive.

In conclusion, while the EU's governance structures have been designed to maintain stability and the status quo, they must also be open to democratic reforms to ensure the continued trust and support of its citizens. The challenges and political developments within and beyond the EU underscore the importance of a balanced and inclusive approach to leadership and governance.