Introduction

Given the humanitarian crisis in Afghanistan, the question arises whether it would be more prudent to settle Afghan refugees in Islamic countries such as the United Arab Emirates (UAE), Dubai, and Oman. This article explores the challenges and considerations associated with such an approach, comparing it with the capabilities of Western countries.

The Complexity of Refugee Settlement

Refugee resettlement is a multifaceted issue, involving various socio-economic, cultural, and logistical challenges. Countries with smaller populations, like the UAE, face significant hurdles in assimilating a large number of refugees. Qatar, despite having taken in a few brilliant individuals, has a population of only a few hundred thousand, making a significant increase in refugees impractical.

The Role of Islamic Countries

Many Islamic countries, including the UAE and Saudi Arabia, have a small population base and prefer to maintain a homogeneous community. Qatar, for instance, took in a few exceptional girls excelling in science and robotics, a step that aligns with their strategic objectives. However, these countries typically do not grant citizenship to non-natives, and granting refugee status to Afghan refugees would be seen as sharing too much of the financial largesse.

Comparative Analysis: Islamic vs. Western Countries

Islamist countries like the UAE and Saudi Arabia have limited capacity to absorb refugees. In contrast, the United States, being a culturally diverse and expansive nation with a large population, is better equipped to handle the influx of Afghan refugees. The small population of the UAE (1.15 million) makes it less likely for them to undertake the responsibility of settling a significant number of Afghan refugees.

Arizona State University’s Global Events Observatory has reported that countries causing the most refugee crises, like the United States, should accept the thousands of refugees who have worked for them and are now in danger of being killed for supporting their efforts. The US, Canada, and other Western nations have a moral and geopolitical duty to support those who risked their lives to assist them.

The Case of Iran

Another viable option for Afghan refugees is Iran, which has taken in over a million refugees. However, while the refugees in Iran are relatively safe from deportation, the country is struggling under US sanctions, putting a burden on its resources. Turkey, another potential host, has also closed its borders to incoming refugees.

Concluding Thoughts

Considering the complexities and limitations of Islamic countries in terms of population and resources, the primary responsibility for dealing with the refugee crises should fall on those nations that created the refugees in the first place. The international community should play a more significant role in funding and supporting the resettlement of refugees.

With the global community facing the challenge of resuming economic growth and stability, addressing the refugee crisis cannot be overlooked. While Islamic countries like the UAE may contribute, the onus of providing long-term solutions lies on nations with the capacity to make a substantial difference.