Why Not Celebrate Indigenous Peoples Day?

The idea of dedicating a day to honor Native Americans or Indigenous Peoples has been under discussion for some time. Many holidays, such as Martin Luther King Jr. Day, Presidents' Day, Mother's Day, and Father's Day, celebrate specific groups, yet a dedicated day for Indigenous Peoples remains a contentious topic. This article explores the reasons behind the current debate and considers the cultural and historical significance of such a celebration.

The History of Columbus Day and Its Controversies

Columbus Day, celebrating the supposed discovery of the New World by Christopher Columbus, has been a contentious holiday. Many Indigenous activists argue that it should be abolished or repurposed. They assert that it does not honor the rich history and contributions of Native Americans but rather celebrates a European arrival that led to significant suffering and displacement for Indigenous peoples.

A Boast vs. Subversion of Existing Holidays

The argument against creating a separate Indigenous Peoples Day is often framed as a vain attempt to further divide American society. Critics argue that it is not beneficial to divide America into numerous minority holidays and that Columbus Day should be removed, as it is celebrated on the Friday after Thanksgiving. Removing Columbus Day would not only simplify the holiday schedule but also address the historical inaccuracies and racial implications attached to the holiday.

Work Days and Holiday Flexibility

Minor national holidays, such as Columbus Day and Presidents' Day, are typically workdays for most Americans. This means that many businesses must compensate for these days, which can be costly. However, this does not preclude individuals from celebrating Indigenous Peoples Day or any other holidays as they see fit. Just as there are various dates for celebrating other cultural holidays (such as Saint Patrick's Day or Cinco de Mayo), there is no reason why Indigenous Peoples Day should not be observed.

Personal Connection and Cultural Identity

As a self-identified Native American, the author argues that everyone, regardless of their heritage, should have the freedom to celebrate and honor their cultural roots. This is akin to other cultural celebrations like Halloween, Valentine’s Day, or Saint Patrick’s Day, which are widely embraced by various groups. Florists, for example, often have the same number of inquiries for flower delivery on other holidays, demonstrating that people can find joy in multiple celebrations.

Contrasting Realities: Race, History, and Political Sensitivities

The argument against Indigenous Peoples Day is sometimes rooted in the hope that it would dilute the impact of established holidays like Martin Luther King Jr. Day. However, as several Southern states already celebrate Confederate heroes on MLK Day, it is clear that the principle of political appropriation of holidays can indeed affect how holidays are perceived. This is an important issue to consider, as it reflects broader debates about race, history, and political correctness in the United States.

Trends and Developments

Trends across the United States are showing a shift towards recognizing Indigenous Peoples Day. Many cities have already ditched Columbus Day in favor of Indigenous Peoples Day. This movement reflects a broader acknowledgment of the historical and cultural significance of Native American heritage and tribal sovereignty. By honoring Indigenous Peoples Day, these communities are asserting their place in American history and culture.

Conclusion: A Balance Between Celebration and Recognition

The idea of a dedicated Indigenous Peoples Day is not about sowing division but about recognizing and celebrating a rich history. While some argue that dividing the nation further with too many minority holidays is not advisable, the fact remains that such celebrations do not need to be divisive. Instead, they can be a way to foster understanding, respect, and honor for the cultures that have shaped America. As we move forward, it is crucial to find a way to balance celebration and recognition with a deep understanding of our shared past.