Why Does Narendra Modi Never Speak Against Amit Shah?

Introduction

Narendra Modi's cabinet includes Amit Shah, who serves as the Home Minister of India. This partnership is often discussed in the media, particularly in contexts where tensions arise. A common narrative is that while Amit Shah speaks out publicly, Narendra Modi remains silent. This article aims to dissect the reasons behind this phenomenon, explore the potential implications, and discuss how it aligns with broader political strategies.

Secrets of Narendra Modi

It is widely speculated that Amit Shah, as the Home Minister, is aware of the private and sensitive aspects of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's political maneuvers. The secrecy and intelligence gathered through Shah suggest that Modi has a clear strategy in place to shield himself from direct criticism or accusation.

Controversies and Missteps

Several instances have led to questions about the dynamics between these two key figures. In 2005, officials under Amit Shah were involved in an encounter with Sohrabuddin Tulsi and others, allegations that surface periodically and complicate the relationship between the two.

Resolving Conflicts

Narendra Modi's silence against Amit Shah could be seen as a strategic choice rather than an indifference to controversies. For example, in the Sohrabuddin Tulsi encounter case, Modi did not speak out, allowing the matter to be addressed without direct interference. This leaves the stage open for other parties to handle the controversy.

Strategic Choices

One aspect to consider is the broader political strategy employed by Modi. When faced with unfavorable situations, such as corruption allegations or legal inquiries, Modi often chooses to remain silent, allowing other parties to address the controversy. This strategy can be seen as a protective measure, safeguarding his image and avoiding additional public scrutiny.

Modi's Sister and Cousin

There is a significant portion of the public who wonder why Narendra Modi does not speak up about issues closer to him, such as his family members. For instance, his cousin still works as an autorickshaw driver. This situation raises questions about Modi's priorities and the real state of his family's welfare despite his public persona of socio-economic growth. It also highlights the contrast between his personal life and his role as Prime Minister.

Modi's Strategy and Silence

The concept of "When the going gets tough, the tough get going" is often used to describe this behavior. However, a more accurate metaphor might be "When the going gets tough, some go silent." Modiji's decision to stay silent on certain issues is a strategic choice to minimize backlash and maintain a calm image. This approach is particularly evident during political crises, such as those involving the JNU Anti-National issue, the implementation of GST, and the involvement in controversies like the Sohrabuddin Tulsi case.

Conclusion

While it may appear that Narendra Modi never speaks against Amit Shah, it is crucial to understand that this silence serves a strategic purpose. It protects his image, minimizes political fallout, and allows situations to be managed without direct interference. The public should question the implications of this silence and the broader context within which it occurs, ensuring a balanced and informed perspective.

Key Points

Secrets and intelligence gathered by Amit Shah inform Modi's decision-making. Silence strategically chosen to maintain a positive public image and avoid backlash. Focus on broader political dynamics and less on personal or familial issues.