Why Armenians from Armenia Feel Closer to Georgians Than Assyrians

The perceptions of closeness among Armenians, Georgians, and Assyrians are influenced by a variety of factors including historical relationships, geopolitical contexts, cultural exchanges, and shared experiences. This article explores why Armenians from Armenia might feel a stronger connection to Georgians compared to Assyrians despite cultural, historical, and genetic ties to the latter.

Geopolitical Context

Armenia and Georgia are both located in the South Caucasus region and share borders and historical interactions. Their proximity has fostered a sense of regional identity and mutual understanding, especially in the context of post-Soviet developments where both countries have navigated similar political landscapes. This shared geopolitical context has led to a closer relationship and a stronger sense of mutual support and understanding.

Shared History

Throughout history, Armenians and Georgians have often collaborated and supported each other, particularly during periods of foreign domination such as the Ottoman and Persian Empires. This historical bond is an important factor in their relationship and has created a unique connection that may not exist to the same extent with Assyrians, who have had a different historical trajectory. Shared experiences of survival and adaptation during these challenging times have strengthened their bond.

Cultural Exchanges

There are significant cultural exchanges between Armenians and Georgians, including shared traditions, languages, and religious practices. Both cultures belong to the Caucasian cultural sphere, and their participation in similar religious practices, primarily Christianity (Armenian Apostolic Church and Georgian Orthodox Church), has historically interacted to reinforce these cultural ties. The intermingling of cultures has created a rich tapestry of shared customs and rituals that further bind these communities together.

Diaspora and Modern Politics

The Armenian diaspora has significant communities in Georgia, leading to ongoing interactions and shared experiences. In contrast, the Assyrian diaspora is more dispersed and less influential in the South Caucasus region. The diaspora also plays a crucial role in shaping perceptions of closeness. Modern political dynamics and alliances can also shape these relationships. Shared political struggles and alliances may foster a sense of solidarity, while conflicting interests can create distance.

Language and Identity

While Armenians and Assyrians share linguistic roots in the broader Semitic and Indo-European families, the Armenian language and identity have developed distinctly within the Caucasian context. This may lead to a stronger identification with Georgian culture, which is also unique to the region. The distinct cultural and linguistic identity can create a stronger bond with communities that share a similar regional identity.

Historical Conflicts

Tensions and conflicts in the Middle East, particularly involving Assyrian communities, have sometimes created barriers to connection with Armenians. Conversely, shared struggles against common historical adversaries can foster a sense of solidarity with Georgians. Historical conflicts can exacerbate divisions, while shared challenges can strengthen bonds. The geopolitical landscape of the Middle East has influenced these relationships, with conflicts often leading to isolation and a stronger sense of community among those who share common struggles.

In summary, while Armenians may share deep cultural, historical, and genetic ties with Assyrians, the geographical proximity, shared historical experiences, and cultural exchanges with Georgians often lead to a stronger sense of closeness in contemporary contexts. These factors create a complex web of relationships that shape the perception of closeness among these communities.