The Myth of 'True Whites' Among European Ethnicities

Recently, the concept of 'true whites' has been brought up, especially in discussions involving European ethnicities. This article aims to clarify the diverse genetic makeup of Europeans and the historical and cultural context that has shaped the concept of whiteness.

Genetic Diversity Among Europeans

Contrary to popular belief, there is no such thing as 'true whites.' Europeans, like any other population, share a common ancestry at different percentages. For instance, Southern Europeans carry more Anatolian DNA, while Northern Europeans carry more Indo-European DNA. The Indo-Europeans were a mix of West Asians and Eastern hunter-gatherers, showing the complexity of European genetic history.

Benjamin Franklin's Perspective on Whiteness

Some may find it surprising that in the 18th century, Benjamin Franklin, a significant figure in American history, listed the French, Germans, Russians, and Swedes among those with tawny or swarthy skin tones. According to him, the only true whites were the English and the Saxons. This perspective highlights how the concept of 'whiteness' has evolved over time.

European Ethnicities and the Concept of 'Whiteness'

Whiteness as it is perceived now is vastly different from what it was in Franklin's Anglo-Saxon era. Traditional white ethnicities include:

English Welsh Scots Northern Irish or British Irish Gypsy or Irish Travellers Roma Alpine race Armenoid race Mediterranean race Nordic race

While these groups have roots in Europe, the concept of 'whiteness' is not unique to them. Historically, European nations had more pressing concerns, such as religious differences or flags, rather than skin color. This historical context should be considered when discussing the concept of 'true whites'.

The Evolution of 'Whiteness' in the United States

In the United States, the meaning of 'white' has not been static. Initially, 'white' only included Protestant Northern Europeans, primarily Britons and Dutch. Over time, the definition expanded to include anyone in Europe and even pale-skinned Levantines and North Africans. Therefore, any discussion about 'true whites' in the U.S. is a misunderstanding and a form of racism.

The Importance of a Universal Perspective on Race

In Europe, we recognize humanity as one race. These false notions of racism are prevalent in other regions like Africa and South America, but not in Europe. It is essential to focus on inclusivity and recognize the diverse backgrounds that make up Europe. The Brits, for instance, have historically created a hierarchical society based on race and color, which continues to influence modern discussions.

Understanding the diversity and historical context is crucial in dispelling myths about 'true whites' among European ethnicities. By acknowledging and celebrating our genetic and cultural diversity, we can build a more inclusive and equitable society.