The Ambiguous Portrait of Pakistan's Best Man: Dr. Abdul Qadeer Khan and Justice Saqib Nisar

The title of 'the best man' in Pakistan is a subject of debate often centered around individuals who have significantly impacted the nation. Two notable figures come to mind: Dr. Abdul Qadeer Khan and Justice Saqib Nisar. Each has made considerable contributions, but their legacies are ambivalent.

Dr. Abdul Qadeer Khan: The Nuclear Pioneer

Dr. Abdul Qadeer Khan, often referred to as the 'father of Pakistan's nuclear program,' has been a controversial figure since the dawn of Pakistan's nuclear ambitions. His contributions have been instrumental in safeguarding the country from external threats. However, his methods and the broader implications of Pakistan’s nuclear program have been widely debated and criticized. For those who value national security over ethical considerations, Dr. Khan stands out as a national hero and protector.

The rationale behind choosing Dr. Khan as the best man is rooted in his role in ensuring the stability and security of Pakistan. However, his legacy also includes significant controversies, including allegations of risking international relations and civil liberties.

Justice Saqib Nisar: The Champion of Integrity

Justice Saqib Nisar, the Honorable Chief Justice of Pakistan, has endeared himself to many with his speeches and actions that emphasize the independence and integrity of the judiciary. In his speech on December 16, 2017, he likened the judiciary to a wise elder, a Baba Rehmat, emphasizing that it is not subject to political pressures and is independent in its decisions. He also highlighted the role of the judiciary in providing essential services and addressing administrative issues.

During visits to Mayo Hospital in Lahore on December 19, 2017, and the Services Hospital and Punjab Institute of Cardiology in March 2018, Justice Nisar demonstrated his commitment to improving public services. His directives for clean drinking water and separate wards for men and women reflect his deep concern for public health and social justice. He also showed that he is not solely focused on formal judicial duties but extends his efforts to help the needy directly.

Effectiveness of the Judiciary

While Justice Saqib Nisar's actions and words have earned him recognition, there is a stark contrast in the effectiveness of the judiciary as a whole. The principle of justice delayed is justice denied remains a serious issue in Pakistan. A report suggests that two in five Pakistanis believe the judiciary is corrupt. This undermines public trust and the overall functioning of the justice system.

Pending Cases and Corruption

The Supreme Court alone has a backlog of over 2.1 million cases as of 2022. Delays in resolving these cases have massive repercussions. Justice delayed often means justice denied, fostering a culture where crime might seem rewarded and lawlessness thrives. This is not just a problem at the provincial or local level but is endemic across the different levels of the judiciary.

Justice Nisar's unannounced visit to the lower courts, such as the Lahore District and Sessions Courts, would have significantly contributed to understanding and addressing the issues of corruption and inefficiency. This step would have helped rethink the current administrative and judicial practices and foster harmony between the populace and the judiciary.

Conclusion: A Nation's Best Man

The title of 'the best man' in Pakistan is a complex honor, one that comes with great responsibilities and also carries the mantle of criticism. Both Dr. Abdul Qadeer Khan and Justice Saqib Nisar have made remarkable contributions, albeit in different spheres. The best man in Pakistan would be one who not only safeguards national security and integrity but also pioneers reforms to ensure a more just and efficient judicial system. Until this is achieved, the quest for the best man in Pakistan remains an ongoing debate.

References:

Google Images