Perspective in Healthcare: Addressing Patronization in Nurse-Doctor Relations

It is perhaps safe to assume that nurses often face a unique set of challenges in their professional lives, particularly when encountering doctors. The dynamic between nurses and doctors varies widely, with some interactions marked by collaboration and respect, while others are riddled with challenges like patronization. Despite the varying experiences, understanding and addressing incidents of patronization is crucial for fostering a positive and productive work environment.

Incidents of Patronization in Healthcare

Patronization, whether intentional or not, can be an unfortunate yet prevalent issue in the medical field. As a nurse, I have had encounters that left a lasting impression. For instance, during my tenure in an intermediate care unit, I witnessed a heated argument between two doctors over an administrative issue. In one incident, a doctor's frustration was directed towards me, a staff member, instead of his colleague. This resulted in me being struck by a flying chart, a display of more rudeness than professionalism. Another instance involved a very agitated 87-year-old patient with sundowners. Despite needing medication to stay in bed post-procedure, the resident doctor initially refused to prescribe it, insisting that I wait for further instructions. These incidents highlight the potential harm caused by patronizing behavior in the medical setting.

Impact on Healthcare Providers

The impact of patronization on healthcare providers extends beyond just missed opportunities for effective care and leads to significant stress and frustration. It can erode trust, diminish the efficacy of team collaboration, and ultimately affect the quality of patient care. Furthermore, such interactions can also contribute to a climactic work environment where staff are more likely to feel undervalued and overworked.

As a senior charge nurse, I have spent years in acute and rehabilitation psychiatry, where the stakes are even higher. The treatment of psychiatric patients necessitates not only strong medical skills but also a deep understanding of psychology and patient behavior. It is in these settings that issues of patronization can be particularly damaging, as they can undermine the therapeutic relationship between healthcare providers and patients.

Combating Patronization

Addressing patronization requires a multifaceted approach. For individuals such as myself, assertiveness and authority are key. Knowing one's subject matter well and being able to speak with authority ensures that interactions are both respectful and effective. Additionally, seeking advice from trusted experts whenever necessary can strengthen one's position. However, being assertive has its downsides, including a potential loss of popularity or opportunities for promotion. Nonetheless, the personal satisfaction and fulfillment gained from standing up for professional principles and values are invaluable.

While personally navigating the challenges of professional respect, it is also crucial to advocate for colleagues facing similar situations. Over the years, I have been involved in several high-stress situations, including public defamation, industrial tribunals, and court cases, all revolving around instances of patronizing behavior. These experiences, though stressful, have solidified my commitment to fostering a respectful and professional environment.

Building a Respectful Work Environment

Creating a work environment characterized by mutual respect and collaboration is essential. It is important to recognize and value consultative colleagues who work in a sharing and cooperative manner. Nurturing such relationships can lead to a more positive and less stressful work environment. On the contrary, being prepared for those who may attempt to assert their dominance is necessary to maintain professionalism.

Ultimately, cultivating a mindset of kindness and positivity is beneficial. Extending friendly greetings and showing interest in one's colleagues can prevent many instances of patronizing behavior. By setting a positive tone, one can foster a community where mutual respect is the norm.

With these insights, it is clear that managing and mitigating instances of patronization is vital for the well-being and effectiveness of healthcare professionals and the quality of patient care they provide.

/div /div