Misconceptions Surrounding Meghan Markle and the Censure of Baby Showers

There are numerous misconceptions and criticisms surrounding Meghan Markle and her approach to pre-birth celebrations. The idea that she was prevented from hosting a baby shower before the birth of her child, which has been widely reported, is a narrative that has become deeply ingrained in public discourse. However, delving into the nuances of royal protocol and common practices in the UK and US, it becomes evident that these narratives often mix fact with fiction.

Unsubstantiated Claims and Personal Biases

It is noteworthy that Meghan Markle has not publicly confirmed or denied the specific instances mentioned. Critics, many who hold personal biases against her, often cite these anecdotes, which have been challenged and debunked by various sources. For example, the claim that she was not allowed to hold a baby shower, or that her passport was taken away, lacks substantial evidence to support it. These unsubstantiated claims often serve to fuel a narrative of conflict rather than to clarify the truth.

Royal Protocol and Celebrations

The tradition of baby showers in the UK and the UK royal family differs from what might be customary in the United States. In the UK, and specifically among the royal family, there is a tradition of celebrate milestones after the child is born. This practice is rooted in the principle of recognizing the Crown and the broader societal role that the child will eventually assume. The royal family prefers to acknowledge the royal status of the infant after birth, which includes receiving gifts that are formally recognized as tributes to the Crown.

It is important to understand that the monarch and the royal family receive a significant number of gifts, which are often donated to charity or the Crown's collections. The practice of a baby shower costing hundreds of thousands of dollars is not in line with the traditions and restrictions the royal family follows. This includes the adherence to gifts that are not meant to benefit an individual but the institution as a whole.

For instance, when Meghan Markle married Prince Harry, she received a highly valuable pair of earrings as a wedding gift from the Prince of Saudi Arabia. However, when she was asked to return the earrings due to the royal gift policy, she "lost" them. This incident further underscores the complications and expectations surrounding gift giving for the royal family, particularly for events like a baby shower.

Cultural Differences in Celebrations

In the US, baby showers are a more common and celebrated tradition. They are typically informal gatherings with friends and family who contribute to the birth preparations and newborn's future. This is a personal celebration, distinct from the royal protocol of the UK. In Europe, particularly the UK, pre-birth celebrations are less formal and are more about the community celebration post-birth. This shift in customs reflects a broader cultural shift and understanding of royal protocol.

Conclusion

The controversy around Meghan Markle's planned baby shower and subsequent events brings to light the cultural and traditional differences regarding celebrations before and after the birth of a royal child. These differences are not just about personal preferences but are deeply rooted in the unique responsibilities and expectations of the royal family. It is crucial to approach discussions with a balanced perspective, recognizing the complex interplay of personal and institutional roles.

While Meghan Markle's behavior within these traditions can often be critiqued, it is also important to acknowledge that she, like many others, may struggle with the unique pressures of being a public figure in a highly scrutinized royal family. These pressures are significant and often underreported.