Do People from Scotland and Wales Prefer to Be Called British or Scottish and Welsh?

The preference for identity among people from Scotland and Wales can vary significantly based on individual perspectives and cultural context. This article explores the nuances and cultural implications of being referred to as 'Scottish' or 'Welsh' versus 'British'.

Scotland

Many Scots identify strongly with their Scottish identity and may prefer to be called Scottish over other labels. As seen in the following quote:

I am Scottish and I would prefer to be referred to as such. I am Scottish first and British second.

Others, while not opposing the idea of calling themselves British, may find it insufficient:

I’m Welsh but I don’t mind being called British. Wales is part of the United Kingdom of Great Britain.

Some individuals believe that while their choice of identity label is personal, it often has more to do with historical and cultural contexts. The passage of time and oppressive histories have shaped their identity:

Most identify as I do, as Scottish/Welsh then British then European which is sweet FA to do with the EU or Brexit but to do with the common elements of our old and shared culture.

Wales

Similarly, many Welsh people prefer to be identified as Welsh. As expressed in one individual’s statement:

As I have been born and raised in North Wales I have always identified as being Welsh.

They emphasize that it is more than just a linguistic challenge but a statement of cultural pride and identity:

For us it’s quite offensive to be called British. As we are a nation with our own language Cymraeg/Welsh and culture.

The historical struggles and the efforts to preserve their language contribute significantly to their preference:

Might this be because we have been oppressed by England for so many years? They’ve drowned village Tryweryn, they’ve tried to kill our language Welsh Not.

Context and Attitude

It is important to note that identity preference can vary, and not everyone feels strongly about it. Many individuals adhere to a live and let live approach:

It depends a lot on the context and a live and let live attitude. I make similar mistakes calling Bashkirians Russian because they are from the Russian federation and not considering if their loyalties are firstly to the Republic of Bashkortistan.

Identity is complex, and while some are very particular about their labels, others are less concerned as long as there is no implication of a political or cultural agenda:

Most don’t care unless the caller is trying to label them with a political/cultural agenda.

Conclusion

The preference for being called 'Scottish,' 'Welsh,' or 'British' is deeply rooted in cultural and historical contexts. For many, the label signifies a connection to their heritage, language, and national pride. Understanding these nuances is crucial for respectful communication and fostering unity and diversity within the United Kingdom.