As a DM, Would You Allow a Centaur PC to Use the Horseshoes of Speed in DD 5e?

In Dungeons Dragons 5th Edition, the Horseshoes of Speed are designed to be used on a horse, granting it increased speed and the ability to dash as a bonus action. Since centaurs are considered humanoids with the ability to traverse terrain like a horse, the decision to allow a centaur player character (PC) to use the Horseshoes of Speed depends largely on your interpretation of the item and your campaign's rules.

Considerations for Allowing Horseshoes of Speed on a Centaur

Creature Type

Centaurs are classified as humanoids but they have features similar to horses. You could argue that the shoes would fit them thematically and mechanically. However, as a DM, you need to weigh this argument with other factors such as balance and the overall game experience.

Item Description

The item specifies that it is designed for horses. You might want to consider whether the intent of the item was to enhance speed for traditional horses only or if it could be applicable to other horse-like creatures. The Horseshoes of Speed grant a walking speed increase of 30 feet, and the item description mentions 'horse or similar creature.' This ambiguity can be open to interpretation.

Balancing the Rules

Consider how this would affect game balance. Centaurs already have a higher base speed of 40 feet compared to many other races. Adding the benefits of the Horseshoes of Speed, which increase speed further, could lead to potential balance issues. You might want to ensure that the overall gameplay remains fair and enjoyable for all players.

Role-Playing and Flavor

If allowing the centaur to use the shoes adds to the fun and flavor of the game without breaking it, it could be a good choice. As a DM, you have the responsibility to create an immersive and balanced experience for all players. A well-balanced game enhances the overall fun and engagement for everyone involved.

Conclusion

As a DM, you have the final say in this matter. If you feel that allowing a centaur to use the Horseshoes of Speed would enhance the game and not disrupt balance, it could be a fun addition. However, it’s important to communicate with your players and consider the implications for gameplay. Alternatively, you could create a modified version of the item specifically for centaurs to maintain balance while still providing a speed boost.

I am not a DM, but if I was, I would look at the description of the ability or spell to see if it would apply. The Horseshoes of Speed state, 'These iron horseshoes come in a set of four. While all four shoes are affixed to the hooves of a horse or similar creature they increase the creature’s walking speed by 30 feet.' This description provides an implicit ruling that a centaur would count as a similar creature.