Introduction to the Debate on Open Borders

The ongoing debate over open borders in America is one of the most contentious issues in contemporary politics. This essay explores the arguments for and against open borders, delving into the complex implications for national survival, economic benefits, and societal cohesion.

Arguments For Open Borders

The Argument for Surviving Without Borders

Survival Argument: Many advocate for open borders based on the assumption that citizens will die if the borders remain closed. They argue that without the influx of immigrants, the country cannot sustain its population and economy. This perspective suggests that open borders are necessary for a country's survival.

Continuous Immigration Since Time Immemorial

Natural Immigration: It is important to note that people have been crossing borders both legally and illegally long before the existence of current border policies. For instance, before the U.S. had a formal border, immigrants were still coming over. This historical context challenges the notion that modern borders are a recent invention.

Arguments Against Open Borders

Survival Without Immigrants vs. Survival With Them

Delusion of Independence: Some argue that closing the borders is a matter of survival, believing that citizens can thrive without immigrants. This viewpoint is under the delusion that the country can sustain itself without the contributions of immigrants.

Importance of Border Control

National Sovereignty: The argument that a country cannot exist without borders points to the necessity of border control. Legitimate concerns include the protection of national resources and the prevention of illegal activities. Without proper controls, these aspects may be jeopardized.

Public Safety and Economic Impact

Security and Stability: Open borders can pose significant risks to public safety and economic stability. Illegal immigrants often engage in criminal activities or use false identities, which can undermine societal trust and economic growth.

Economic Advantages of Controlled Immigration

Asset to the Country: Legal immigrants undergo inspections and training, making them valuable assets to their new country. They contribute to the economy, fill labor gaps, and add diversity to the workforce. The U.S. has a rich history of benefiting from controlled immigration policies, showcasing the long-term advantages of such approaches.

The Reality of Illegal Immigration

Danger of Unprocessed Immigrants

No Benefit to the US: Allowing a surge of unprocessed immigrants can be catastrophic for the country. A large influx of unverified immigrants can strain resources, impact public services, and destabilize communities. Controlled entry through standard processes is crucial for ensuring the well-being of all residents.

Legal and Tax Issues

Taxes and Workforce: Even legal immigrants often face challenges in the labor market and in terms of tax compliance. Many do not have work permits and cannot pay income taxes. Those who work illegally engage in a range of activities, including identity theft and thievery. The presence of illegal immigrants can create an uneven playing field in the workforce, affecting both the immigrants and the citizens.

Conclusion

The debate over open borders is not black and white, but deeply nuanced. While some argue that open borders are a matter of survival, others contend that closed borders are essential for national security and stability. The key lies in finding a balance that maximizes the benefits of immigration while mitigating its potential downsides.